GS IAS Logo

< Previous | Contents | Next >

Answer:

Democracy in India rests on the constitutional scheme of separation of powers between the three organs of the government, with adequate checks and balances to ensure that the rights of the citizens are duly protected and there is no misuse of power. A judiciary free from encroachments, pressures and interference is an integral part of this scheme.

The Indian judiciary, with the Supreme Court (SC) at the apex and High Courts (HCs) at the state level, has been assigned a very significant role in the Indian democratic system. The SC is a federal court, the highest court of appeal and the guardian of the Constitution. Along with the HCs, it is the guarantor of the fundamental rights of the citizens.

Independence of judiciary is ensured by following safeguards:

Mode of appointment – Appointment of judges of the SC and the HC is done by the President on the recommendation of the collegium of the judiciary. This ensures that absolute discretion of the executive is curtailed and judicial appointments are not based on political considerations.

Security of tenure – Judges can be removed only on the grounds mentioned in the constitution.

Conduct of Judges cannot be discussed in any legislature except when impeachment motion is under consideration.

Fixed service conditions – The salary, allowances, privileges etc. cannot be changed to their disadvantage after appointment

Expenses charged on Consolidated Fund – therefore free from annual parliamentary voting.

Power to punish for its contempt – Thus, its actions and decisions cannot be opposed or criticised arbitrarily.

Other provisions – such as Ban on practice after retirement, no power with Parliament to curtail its jurisdiction, Freedom to appoint its staff etc. also helps in maintaining its independence.

In a democratic polity, all power is held in trust of the people and must be exercised for the people. Therefore, while safeguarding judicial independence, it is essential to balance it with judicial accountability and transparency.